Polish-Jewish Relations: 1,300 Keyword-Phrase-Indexed Book Reviews (by Jan Peczkis)



Wounded Poland’s Reprivatization Unsolvable and Monumental

Postwar: a History of Europe Since 1945, by Tony Judt. 2005. Penguin Press, New York

Poland’s Reprivatization Unsolvable. Say “NO”! to the Holocaust Industry

Poland’s reprivatization unsolvable? Indeed. Author Tony Judt has an excellent grasp of the property-succession conundrums that have resulted from Poland’s Soviet-imposed Communist government, and of which the Holocaust Industry has attempted to take advantage. Any “solution” to the reprivatization problem is arbitrary: It can only create winners and losers. And we must not let the Jews be the winners yet again.

WHY IS POLAND’S REPRIVATIZATION UNSOLVABLE?

Here is how the author describes it, “Between 1945 and 1989 the accumulation of deportations, imprisonments, show trials, and ‘normalizations’ have made almost everyone in the Soviet bloc either a loser or else complicit in someone else’s loss. Apartments, shops, and other property that had been appropriated from dead Jews or expelled Germans were all too often re-appropriated a few years later in the name of Socialism–with the result that after 1989 the question of compensation for past losses became hopelessly tangled in dates. Should people be recompensed for what they lost when the Communists seized power? And it such restitution were made, to whom should it go? To those who had come into possession of it after the war, in 1945, only to lose it a few years later? Or should restitution be made to the heirs of those from whom business and apartments had been seized or stolen at some point between 1938 and 1945? Which point? 1938? 1939? 1941? On each date there hung politically sensitive definitions of national or ethnic legitimacy as well as moral precedence.” (p. 823).

Good questions! Poland’s reprivatization unsolvable, for which reason alone the Holocaust Industry should be stopped dead in its tracks. For more on the impossibility of fairly dividing old Communist-seized property, see:

https://www.jewsandpolesdatabase.org/2019/11/04/inconistent-restitution-claims-levin/

https://www.jewsandpolesdatabase.org/2021/02/04/jan-t-gross-rerun-property-restitution-laws-postwar-polish-privations-detailed-nsz-zolnierze-wykleci-kryzanowski-and-levine/

HOLOCAUST SUPREMACY RULES EUROPE: HOW TO COMBAT IT

Tony Judt makes this clear, “By the end of the twentieth century the centrality of the Holocaust in Western European identity and memory seemed secure.” (p. 10).  That’s for sure.

The author also suggests how Holocaust supremacy can finally be tossed into the rubbish heap of history. Focus on human suffering, and not on the competitive suffering of groups! He comments, “Human suffering should not be calibrated according to the goals of the perpetrators. In this way of reasoning, for those being punished or killed there, a Communist camp is no better or worse than a Nazi camp.” (p. 828. Emphasis added). Finally, some common sense.

 

 

 

 

Spread the Word:
To see a series of reviews in a Category click on that Category:
categories

Jedwabne Lie Getting Exposed:
Jews Hopping Mad!

Total hits:

564,822

Spread the Word

© 2019 All Rights Reserved. Jews and Poles Database