White Privilege Fallacy. The Nonsense of Wokeness. White-On-White Racism Against Poles. Rzepnikowska
Racism and Xenophobia Experienced by Polish Migrants in the UK Before and After the Brexit Vote, by Alina Rzepnikowska. 2019. JOURNAL OF ETHNIC AND MIGRATION STUDIES 45(1)61-77
Wokeness Nonsense: An Eye-Opening Account of British Poles Facing Racism and Discrimination From Other Whites
This article shatters the commonly promoted notion of wokeism, which would have us believe that only whites can be oppressors and only non-whites can be victims. Let us take a closer look at this.
ALL WHITES ARE NOT THE SAME: WHITES ARE NOT A HOMOGENOUS MASS OF PRIVILEGED OPPRESSORS
The whole notion of whites as a whole being privileged, advanced by today’s wokeism, is as silly as it is racist. Is every single white person supposed to be privileged above every single non-white person?
The “whites are privileged” message is chilling, and reminiscent of the “Jews are privileged” notion promoted by the Nazis. Furthermore, this message reduces “whites” to one homogenous mass and overlooks white-on-white discrimination. Consider the Poles. Rzepnikowska comments, “Fox, Morosanu, and Szilassy (2012) argue that shared whiteness between East European migrants and majority has not exempted the former from racialization.” (p. 62).
She elaborates, “While the existing literature mainly focuses on racism experienced by non-white ethnic minorities, this paper makes an important contribution to the understanding of overlapping racism and xenophobia discussed and experienced by migrant women coming from a predominantly white society. The visible and audible markers of difference, such as Polish registration plates, Polish satellite dish or Polish language make their Otherness visible and audible. It also shows how the homogenous notion of Polish whiteness is contested and how not ‘looking Polish’ may actually be considered as a way to be less stigmatized.” (p. 74).
For more on the political implications of this, see:
WHITE-ON-WHITE RACISM HAS A LONG HISTORY
Rzepnikowska writes:
“Dyer (1997) recognized the distinction between the whiteness of the English, Anglo-Saxons or North Europeans from that of Southern or Eastern Europeans due to the specificity of the former in the past two centuries.” (p. 64).
“While racist and xenophobic violence has been particularly noted following the Brexit vote, Polish migrants experienced various forms of racist abuse before that.” (p. 61).
“As a result of recent large-scale migration of Poles to other European countries, many have become conscious of being white as a result of contact with non-whites, and at times, not-quite-white through contact with the white hosts…” (p. 64).
“For instance, despite ‘becoming white’, the Irish in the UK faced high levels of discrimination until 1970s and 1980s.” (p. 64).
WOKENESS NONSENSE: POLES CAN BE THE OTHER DESPITE BEING WHITE
“The privilege of whiteness disappears once they start speaking. While whiteness allows a certain level of invisibility, foreign accent marks Polish migrants as the Other.” (p. 70).
This kind of discrimination against the “white” Poles was expecially prominent in the case of the Polish DPs right after WWII. See:
To see a series of reviews in a Category click on that Category:
- All Reviews
- Celebrate Poland's Heroic Narrative!
- Censorship Of Poles in Favor of Jews
- Communist and Nazi Crimes Equal. Stalin a Twin of Hitler
- Cultural Marxism
- Current Polish-Jewish Relations
- Follies of POLISH CENTER FOR HOLOCAUST RESEARCH
- German Polonocide in WWII
- German Repentance Jewish-Centered
- Holocaust Education Monopoly
- Holocaust Industry Propaganda
- Holocaust Industry Tactics
- Holocaust Myths
- Holocaust Was Not Special
- Holocaust-Centric Narratives Rule
- Ingratitude To Polish Rescuers of Jews
- Interwar Polish-Jewish Relations: Don't Automatically Blame Everything on Poles
- Jedwabne Provocation: German-Made Holocaust Expanded
- Jewish Collaboration With Nazis
- Jewish Economic Dominance
- Jews and Anti-Christian Tendencies
- Jews Antagonize Poland
- Jews Self-Otherize in Poland
- Media, Hollywood Polonophobia
- No "Civil War": Poland Communized By Soviet Russian Force
- No Polish Complicity in the Holocaust
- Persistent Anti-Polish Trends
- Pogroms Demythologized
- Polish Collaboration With Nazis Insignificant
- Polish Guerrilla Warfare
- Polish Nationalism: The Truth
- Polokaust (Polocaust) Long-Term
- Premodern Poland: Little-Known Facts
- Rescue of Danish Jews Demythologized
- Two Sides to Jewish-Goyish Antagonisms
- Ukrainian-Polish Relations
- Understanding Nazis and Jews
- Western European Threat and the European Union
- Zydokomuna in Action
- Zydokomuna in Jewish Life
