Night Without End (Dalej Jest Noc): Shorter English-Language Version. Grabowski and Engelking
Night Without End: The Fate of Jews in German-Occupied Poland, by Jan Grabowski and Barbara Engelking (eds.) 2022. Indiana University Press
Night Without End Hype: Once Again, Blaming Poles for Alleged Complicity in the Holocaust
On the back cover of this book, Deborah Dwork, Omer Bartov, and Jan T. Gross have posted comments. Check out their grandiose hype: “turning point in scholarship”, “bold and innovative”, “remarkable volume”, “unprecedented reconstruction”, “shocking book”. Wow! And what else?
The excitement about this book stems from its undisguised anti-Polish implications. All three quoted authors make no attempt to hide their glee in the putdown of Poland. They triumphantly invoke: “long taboo in Polish society”, “the extent of local Polish participation in hunting down and murdering their Jewish neighbors”, and “complicity of the local population”.
Actually, far from being remarkable and innovative, this book is a rehash of the usual Judeocentric memes. It also contains a little bit of objectivity, and that is what I primarily focus on in my review.
TIGHT GERMAN RULE OVER POLISH VILLAGES GUARANTEED MANY FUGITIVE JEWS DENOUNCED AND KILLED
This book deliberately confuses alleged “Polish complicity in the Holocaust” with forced Polish participation in German-made Jew-killing institutions. The following is an exception to this false conflation:
Jean-Charles Szurek comments, “The countryside was ruled by German law and the German administrative structure, which was also based on certain formations: Polish Blue police, the fire department, and the village head. The village communities, characterized by strong local bonds and mutual acquaintances, formed a thick network, and every encountered Jew had to be reported or brought to the village head, who had the obligation to hand the person over to the police.” (p. 222). For more on this usually omitted material fact, see:
DEALING WITH FUGITIVE JEWS: SELDOM-MENTIONED FACTORS
The fate of fugitive Jews is customarily presented in a Judeocentric contextual vacuum. Jews are the only possible victims, and Poles are nothing more than context-free agents whose raison d’etre was to help or harm the Jews. In particular, the implications of Jewish flight upon the German-traumatized Poles are ignored.
Jan Grabowski for once shows a glimmer of objectivity as he cites an A. K. report on fugitive Jews (which he qualifies as a “perception” of Jews, as if Jews never could do wrong). He writes, “In the report dated November 1943 (mentioned before), the intelligence unit of the resistance from Wegrow stressed that while wealthy Jews hunkered down in their hideouts on Polish farms, praying for speedy liberation, Jews hiding in the forests were a threat to the local Polish population. ‘They attack the peasants, they steal, and they are often communist [Communist] sympathizers. Once caught by the gendarmes, these “forest Jews” in nearly all cases denounce local inhabitants. They are either vengeful for receiving no help, or they follow the old adage: “I will die, but so will you.”‘” (p. 155).
The foregoing facts can be verified from other sources. Moreover, Jews serving the Germans must also be considered. Tomasz Frydel comments, “Little has been written in a sustained fashion about Jewish informers during the Holocaust in occupied Poland. What we know is piecemeal.” (p. 396).
ZYGMUNT KLUKOWSKI’S DIARY MISREPRESENTED YET AGAIN
In the past, Jan T. Gross and Jan Grabowski have mischaracterized Klukowski’s diary as one that shows how terrible Poles were to Jews. Evidently not wanting to feel left out, Alina Skibinska now gets in the act (pp. 57-58, 63-67, 86, 90, 96-97).
So here we go again in the latest iteration of Night Without End. When it comes to the misuse of Klukowski, it’s the same cherry-picking done in a Judeocentric contextual vacuum. See:
https://www.jewsandpolesdatabase.org/2019/11/04/jew-killing-wwii-by-poles-justified-klukowski/
JAN GRABOWSKI AGAIN RELIES ON THE UNRELIABLE MEMOIR OF SZRAGA FEIVEL BIELAWSKI
Despite being cited by Grabowski as some kind of authority, Bielawski has made obviously incorrect statements and quite a few rather fantastic claims. This is demonstrated in the link immediately above.
For more on the way that Jan Grabowski completely distorts the wartime events in Wegrow County, see:
To see a series of reviews in a Category click on that Category:
- All Reviews
- Celebrate Poland's Heroic Narrative!
- Censorship Of Poles in Favor of Jews
- Communist and Nazi Crimes Equal. Stalin a Twin of Hitler
- Cultural Marxism
- Current Polish-Jewish Relations
- Follies of POLISH CENTER FOR HOLOCAUST RESEARCH
- German Polonocide in WWII
- German Repentance Jewish-Centered
- Holocaust Education Monopoly
- Holocaust Industry Propaganda
- Holocaust Industry Tactics
- Holocaust Myths
- Holocaust Was Not Special
- Holocaust-Centric Narratives Rule
- Ingratitude To Polish Rescuers of Jews
- Interwar Polish-Jewish Relations: Don't Automatically Blame Everything on Poles
- Jedwabne Provocation: German-Made Holocaust Expanded
- Jewish Collaboration With Nazis
- Jewish Economic Dominance
- Jews and Anti-Christian Tendencies
- Jews Antagonize Poland
- Jews Self-Otherize in Poland
- Media, Hollywood Polonophobia
- No "Civil War": Poland Communized By Soviet Russian Force
- No Polish Complicity in the Holocaust
- Persistent Anti-Polish Trends
- Pogroms Demythologized
- Polish Collaboration With Nazis Insignificant
- Polish Guerrilla Warfare
- Polish Nationalism: The Truth
- Polokaust (Polocaust) Long-Term
- Premodern Poland: Little-Known Facts
- Rescue of Danish Jews Demythologized
- Two Sides to Jewish-Goyish Antagonisms
- Ukrainian-Polish Relations
- Understanding Nazis and Jews
- Western European Threat and the European Union
- Zydokomuna in Action
- Zydokomuna in Jewish Life
