Polish-Jewish Relations: 1,300 Keyword-Phrase-Indexed Book Reviews (by Jan Peczkis)



Holocaust Education Inequities: Holocaust is Universal: A Gimmick. Holocaust Overattention. Polish Anti-Defamation Law (“Holocaust Law”) Trashed. Don’t Blame Christianity. Versailles Was Terrible: German Exculpation Debunked. Hilton and Patt

Understanding and Teaching the Holocaust, by Laura Hilton and Avinoam Patt. 2020. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison

Holocaust Preeminence Still Rules. Antisemitism a Manichaean Term. Nazi German Concentration Camps Numerous. More Holocaust-Related Polonophobia

This lengthy book provides a lot of information. I focus on a few relevant items.

“HOLOCAUST UNIQUENESS” IS ALIVE AND WELL

Claims about the supposed uniqueness of the Shoah are the foundation of Holocaust supremacism. Educator Robert Hadley comments, “For many years, the Holocaust was a unique event in human history, transcending any labeling to account for the horrors of the time.” (p. 331). No wonder that the Holocaust dominates the West’s schools.

This has not changed, despite a change in language. Hadley continues, “A 2010 study by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance concludes, ‘A clear and well informed understanding of the Holocaust, THE PARADIGMATIC GENOCIDE, may help educators and students understand other genocides, mass atrocities, and human rights violations.'” (p. 333. Emphasis added). How can the Holocaust be “paradigmatic” unless all other genocides are not?

HOLOCAUST OVERATTENTION

That which is the most significant gets the most attention, and that which gets the most attention is the most significant. That is how most people are conditioned to think. There is no escaping the fact that the Holocaust is treated as more important than all other genocides, if only tacitly. Laura Hilton and Avinoam Patt state the obvious, “Therefore, there are few topics in modern history that draw the attention, both scholarly and public, that the Holocaust does.” (p. 3).

HOLOCAUST UNIVERSALIZATION REJECTED

To begin with, note that the supremacy of the Holocaust is not shed by universalizing it. For instance, no one ever says that “When Poles suffered, all humanity suffered,” or that “When Cambodians suffered, it was a tragedy for all humanity.” Ironically, even the so-called universalization of the Holocaust, commonly used as a deflection or disguise from the fact of Holocaust supremacy, is too much for some Jews. Jonathan Elukin comments, “The Holocaust is being universalized, that is, being treated as a tragedy for all humanity (which in a way it is, of course) and not specifically or exclusively for the Jews. This approach denies the uniqueness of the Jewish experience. Indeed, this ‘theologizing’ of the Holocaust goes further by implicitly arguing that when the Jews suffered, all humanity suffered.” (p. 30).

HOLOCAUST SUPREMACY DEVELOPED DECADES AFTER THE EVENTS

The preeminence of the Holocaust, over all other genocides, is in no sense self-evident. It did not even become a reality until some decades after WWII! Hilton and Patt comment, “While there were a few early trailblazers, only a small number of universities and colleges in the United States had courses focused on the study of the Holocaust by the 1970s…with estimates ranging between 140 and 700 colleges and universities offering them by the late 1980s and an explosion in course creation between 1985 and 1989….The prevalence of teaching the Holocaust at the high school level in the United States follows a similar pattern.” (pp. 5-6).

A SOFTENING OF THE BLAMING OF THE HOLOCAUST ON CHRISTIANITY

Jonathan Elukin writes, “Another problem with the term antisemitism is that it reinforces the idea of a linear and teleological connection (drawing a straight line from early Christianity or even nineteenth-century Germany to Hitler) from the earliest hatred of Jews to the genocidal efforts of the Nazis. This ignores both the historical specificity of post- World War I Germany and factors that not only distinguished Nazi antisemitism but also that led to the Final Solution. Doing so flattens our understanding of the Holocaust and distorts the actual premodern history of Jewish-Christian relations. The nature of Christian attitudes toward Jews in the ancient, medieval, and early modern world is far more diverse and dynamic than a one-dimensional history of animosity toward Jews.” (p. 21. Italics in original). But Christianity still gets ultimately blamed for the Holocaust, as in Holocaust museums.

INADEQUACY OF UMBRELLA TERMS SUCH AS ANTISEMITISM OR ANTIJUDAISM

Antisemitism is a catchall explanation. Elukin comments, “The Manichean quality of anti-Judaism or antisemitism ultimately obscures the much more complicated entanglement of Christianity and Judaism that transcended simple persecution and animus. A great deal of Christian thinking about Judaism was not “anti” in any one dimensional sense.” (p. 27. Italics in original).

THE “INJUSTICES OF VERSAILLES” EXCULPATION FOR NAZISM REJECTED

Some Germans still excuse their ancestors’ support for Hitler by such constructs as the “onerous reparations payments” that the Germans had to pay after their defeat in WWI. These claims are false. Mark Spicka writes, “To contextualize the terms of the treaty [Versailles], point out to students that while Germans perceived the conditions as harsh, they were less punitive than what the Germans demanded from the Russians in the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk in March 1918. Furthermore, the Germans actually paid relatively little of the reparations as stipulated by the treaty.” (p. 34).

PUTTING THE BLAME ON THE POLES

No Holocaust book would be complete without some form of accusation against Poles, and this book does not disappoint. Stephen P. Remy writes, “In no other country has the memory of complicity in the Holocaust been more controversial than Poland, the geographic center of the genocide…” (p. 133).

Waitman Wade Beorn goes further. He repeats egregious falsehoods about  the Polish Antidefamation Law, commonly misnamed “Poland’s Holocaust Law“, as he writes, “In particular, the incomplete coming to terms with the past can be seen in recent Polish legislation attempting to criminalize any implication that Poles collaborated with the Nazis or were complicit in victimizing Jews.” (p. 92).

Contrary to this mendacious canard, the Polish law does not forbid stating or researching the fact that individual Poles collaborated with Nazis. It only criminalizes blaming the entire Polish nation for collaboration. Note also the standard Holocaustspeak phrases “complicity in the Holocaust” (a vague, undefined, and accusatory formulation), and “coming to terms with the past” (another vague, undefined, and accusatory formulation).

In his chapter on collaboration with the Nazis, Steven P. Remy (pp. 134-136) praises Jan T. Gross, and swallows his blame-Poles-for-Jedwabne narrative hook, line, and sinker. He also engages in Zydokomuna denialism.

NONINTUITIVELY-OBVIOUS SCALE OF NAZI GERMAN CAMPS, INCLUDING CONCENTRATION CAMPS

Geoffrey P. Megargee writes, “The camps existed in seemingly incredible numbers: more than forty-four thousand of them between 1933 and 1945, of over two dozen types.” (p. 95).

He adds that, “There were about 1,150 ghettos and roughly 1,900 forced labor camps for Jews.” (p. 106). Obviously, the use of Jews for forced labor was no afterthought.

Spread the Word:
To see a series of reviews in a Category click on that Category:
categories

Jedwabne Lie Getting Exposed:
Jews Hopping Mad!

Total hits:

564,079

Spread the Word

© 2019 All Rights Reserved. Jews and Poles Database