Zegota. Irena Sendler Distorted–In a Book for Children. Rubin
Irena Sendler and the Children of the Warsaw Ghetto, by Susan Goldman Rubin. 2011. Holiday House, New York
Irena Sendler Distorted. A Beautiful Book Marred By Canned Polonophobic Memes
As a professional educator, I at first found this book to be uplifting. Designed for children aged 9-12, it provides a generally accurate account of the heroic actions of the Polish woman Irena Sendler, who, together with Zegota, saved at least 2,000 Jewish children from the Nazis. (p. 35). (Some say 2,500).
THE ESSENCE OF IRENA SENDLER
The book discusses the German-Nazi conquest of Poland, the establishment of the ghettos, Sendler’s social work among the Jews, the doomed Jews in the ghettos, Sendler’s creative ways of smuggling Jewish children out of the ghettos, the heartbreaking parting of parents and children, the refusal of some parents to entrust their children to Sendler, the new lives of the disguised Jewish children, the secret list of parents and children, Sendler’s capture and torture by the Gestapo followed by her bribe-induced release, the Jews’ and later Poles’ Warsaw Uprisings, the children and Irena Sendler after the war, etc.
EXTRANEOUS CONTENT: STANDARD POLONOPHOBIC MEMES
Unfortunately, a number of irrelevant items in this book detract from it. There is mention of the pre-WWII ghetto benches for Jews at Polish universities. (p. 6). This is, at best, tangential to the subject of this book, and, at worst, a relativization of prewar-Polish and later Nazi-German conduct towards Jews (especially in the impressionable child’s mind)–a clear case of relativizing the Holocaust. If Rubin insists on bringing up ghetto benches, she should at least inform the reader that Jews themselves long practiced segregation in their synagogues. (Men sat separate from women, and high-status Jews sat apart from common Jews.)
It gets worse. When Treblinka is referred to in the index, it is termed a “Polish death camp”. (p. 40). Apart from being at-best misleading and at-worst false, it is doubly unacceptable in view of the fact that children tend to think literally.
FURTHER DISTORTIONS OF IRENA SENDLER
Rubin correctly notes that, after WWII, the Communist government persecuted those who had belonged to the anti-Communist mainstream Polish underground, of which Sendler had been a member. However, Rubin also makes the following amazing assertion: “Anti-Semitism swept through Poland again, and Irena was persecuted for having saved Jews.” (p. 37). What kind of persecution was Sendler supposed to have experienced from Polish anti-Semites? Also, if postwar Polish anti-Semitism is to be mentioned at all, then why not also mention some of the Jewish conduct that led to it? Why use an audience of children to blame everything on the Poles? Or is that the whole idea?
To see a series of reviews in a Category click on that Category:
- All Reviews
- Celebrate Poland's Heroic Narrative!
- Censorship Of Poles in Favor of Jews
- Communist and Nazi Crimes Equal. Stalin a Twin of Hitler
- Cultural Marxism
- Current Polish-Jewish Relations
- Follies of POLISH CENTER FOR HOLOCAUST RESEARCH
- German Polonocide in WWII
- German Repentance Jewish-Centered
- Holocaust Education Monopoly
- Holocaust Industry Propaganda
- Holocaust Industry Tactics
- Holocaust Myths
- Holocaust Was Not Special
- Holocaust-Centric Narratives Rule
- Ingratitude To Polish Rescuers of Jews
- Interwar Polish-Jewish Relations: Don't Automatically Blame Everything on Poles
- Jedwabne Provocation: German-Made Holocaust Expanded
- Jewish Collaboration With Nazis
- Jewish Economic Dominance
- Jews and Anti-Christian Tendencies
- Jews Antagonize Poland
- Jews Self-Otherize in Poland
- Media, Hollywood Polonophobia
- No "Civil War": Poland Communized By Soviet Russian Force
- No Polish Complicity in the Holocaust
- Persistent Anti-Polish Trends
- Pogroms Demythologized
- Polish Collaboration With Nazis Insignificant
- Polish Guerrilla Warfare
- Polish Nationalism: The Truth
- Polokaust (Polocaust) Long-Term
- Premodern Poland: Little-Known Facts
- Rescue of Danish Jews Demythologized
- Two Sides to Jewish-Goyish Antagonisms
- Ukrainian-Polish Relations
- Understanding Nazis and Jews
- Western European Threat and the European Union
- Zydokomuna in Action
- Zydokomuna in Jewish Life
